Guide

Are Trustpilot reviews fake? What Trustpilot removes, and how to judge a profile

ReviewGuard team · November 10, 2026 · 4 min read

Short answer: Most Trustpilot reviews are written by real customers, but fake reviews do get submitted, and Trustpilot removes a meaningful share of them. In its 2025 Trust Report (published 29 May 2025), Trustpilot said it removed 4.5 million fake reviews in 2024, 7.4% of all reviews submitted that year, and that 90% of those were removed automatically by its technology. So a profile is not proof on its own: read how recent, how detailed and how balanced the reviews are, and how the business replies.

What Trustpilot says it does about fake reviews

From Trustpilot's 2025 Trust Report press release:

  • 4.5 million fake reviews removed in 2024, equal to 7.4% of the reviews submitted.
  • 90% of those were removed automatically by technology rather than human moderators.
  • It uses AI "guideline software" to flag reviews that breach its guidelines at scale, and technology that looks for evidence that a review was purchased.
  • People flag reviews too: in 2024, about 92 thousand reviews were flagged by consumers and about 601 thousand by businesses for guideline breaches.

Two readings of those numbers are both true: fake reviews are a real, large-scale problem, and a lot of them never make it onto profiles.

How to judge a Trustpilot profile as a shopper

  • Look at the spread, not only the score. A real business usually has some three- and two-star reviews. A wall of identical five-star reviews is a warning sign.
  • Check recency. Are there reviews from the last few weeks, or did they all arrive in one burst months ago?
  • Read the detail. Genuine reviews mention specifics: what was bought, what went wrong, who helped.
  • Read the business's replies. Calm, specific answers to complaints are a better trust signal than the star average.
  • Look at a few reviewer profiles. A history of varied reviews over time is more credible than a profile with one review.
  • Compare with other sources: Google reviews, forums, your own network.

What businesses should do

Don't buy, fake or filter

The temptation is understandable when a competitor seems to have hundreds of glowing reviews. Don't. Trustpilot actively looks for purchased reviews, and in the US the FTC's August 2024 rule prohibits fake reviews (including AI-generated ones), buying reviews conditioned on a positive sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews and review suppression through threats or intimidation. The FTC said it can seek civil penalties against knowing violators.

Earn reviews honestly

Ask every customer, not only the happy ones, at the moment they've received what they paid for, using the platform's own invitation tools. Keep the ask simple and don't attach a reward conditioned on a positive review.

Reply to every review you can

Shoppers read replies. For a negative review: acknowledge the problem specifically, don't argue, offer to fix it offline. For a positive one: thank them and mention something they said. Our guide to responding to reviews has examples that work on Trustpilot too.

Flag what breaks the rules

If a review looks fake (no matching order, a competitor, abusive content), flag it through Trustpilot's tools with the reason. Businesses flagged about 601 thousand reviews in 2024, so this is normal and expected. Don't threaten the reviewer in a public reply.

A routine that keeps your profile healthy

  1. See every new review the day it appears. You can't reply to what you don't notice.
  2. Reply within a few days, starting with low ratings.
  3. Flag only clear guideline breaches, with a short factual reason.
  4. Once a month, read the themes: what keeps coming up in complaints is your to-do list.

ReviewGuard automates steps 1 and 4 and helps with 2: enter your domain and it emails new Trustpilot (and Google) reviews with a reply drafted in your tone, plus a monthly report of recurring themes. It never posts or flags anything for you.

Common misconceptions

  • "Trustpilot is all fake." Trustpilot's own figures show most submitted reviews are not removed as fake; the 7.4% that were is a real problem, not the whole picture.
  • "A business can delete bad Trustpilot reviews." Businesses can flag reviews that breach guidelines; they can't simply delete negative ones.
  • "High score means trustworthy." Look at detail, spread, recency and replies.
  • "Fighting fakes with fakes evens things out." It adds legal and platform risk on top of the original problem.

FAQ

How many Trustpilot reviews are fake? Trustpilot reported removing 4.5 million fake reviews in 2024, 7.4% of submissions. Nobody can say exactly how many fakes are never caught.

Can I report a fake review on Trustpilot? Yes, both consumers and businesses can flag reviews; in 2024, consumers flagged about 92 thousand and businesses about 601 thousand.

Are Google reviews more reliable than Trustpilot? Both platforms remove fake reviews and both have them. Compare sources rather than trusting one. See fake Google reviews.

Sources